Overview
A shareholders' agreement creates the constitution for ownership relationships. While the Companies Act and articles of association establish the baseline corporate framework, the shareholders' agreement addresses matters that shareholders wish to govern contractually among themselves. It can provide protections, impose obligations, and create mechanisms that go beyond what corporate law requires - subject to the constraint that it cannot contradict mandatory statutory provisions.
The need for shareholders' agreements is greatest when shareholders have different characteristics or expectations. When a founder takes investment from venture capital, when family members hold shares across generations, when a joint venture is structured as a company, when management holds equity alongside financial investors - in each case, the diverse interests and capabilities of shareholders require governance frameworks tailored to their specific relationship.
Shareholders' agreements must navigate the relationship between contract and corporate law. Some matters can be addressed either in the SHA or the articles - the choice affects enforceability against the company and future shareholders. Some provisions may conflict with Companies Act requirements and be void. Understanding these boundaries is essential for creating agreements that actually work.
Key Considerations
Governance Rights
Board composition, voting thresholds, reserved matters, and information rights that shape how decisions are made.
Transfer Restrictions
Lock-ups, pre-emption rights, right of first refusal, and approval requirements that control share movement.
Exit Mechanisms
Tag-along, drag-along, put options, and IPO provisions that enable and structure liquidity events.
Anti-dilution
Price-based and structural anti-dilution protections for investors in subsequent financings.
Founder Provisions
Vesting, good leaver/bad leaver, and competing activity restrictions that align founder incentives.
Dispute Resolution
Mechanisms for resolving disputes among shareholders, including deadlock provisions.
Applying the TCL Framework
Technical
- Understanding the business and its technology/IP
- Assessing information systems for reporting requirements
- Evaluating technical capabilities relevant to reserved matters
- Understanding product development and capital needs
- Reviewing technology agreements affecting the company
Commercial
- Aligning governance with shareholder investment theses
- Structuring economics fairly across shareholder classes
- Designing incentive alignment for management shareholders
- Addressing different liquidity expectations and timelines
- Managing related party transaction dynamics
Legal
- Ensuring consistency with Companies Act requirements
- Coordinating with articles of association
- Creating enforceable transfer restrictions
- Addressing conflict between SHA and corporate actions
- Structuring dispute resolution for shareholder conflicts
"A shareholders' agreement is tested not when relationships are good, but when they break down. It must be drafted for the dispute, the exit, the broken relationship - not for the optimistic scenario where everyone agrees."
Common Pitfalls
Articles Conflict
SHA provisions that conflict with the articles of association, creating uncertainty about which governs.
Excessive Reserved Matters
Reserved matter lists so extensive that routine decisions require investor approval, hampering operations.
Exit Impracticality
Exit provisions that sound protective but cannot practically operate when exit opportunities arise.
Valuation Disputes
Valuation mechanisms for transfers or exits that are ambiguous or impractical to apply.
Deadlock Without Resolution
Identifying deadlock scenarios without creating workable resolution mechanisms.
SHA Legal Framework
Shareholders' agreements in India operate within the Companies Act, 2013 framework. The SHA cannot override mandatory statutory provisions but can supplement them. Transfer restrictions and pre-emption rights are enforceable among parties but may need articles amendments to bind the company. SEBI regulations apply to SHAs in listed companies. FDI policy may affect provisions involving foreign shareholders. Competition law may scrutinise shareholder arrangements involving competitors. Tax implications arise from various SHA mechanisms including buybacks and put options.
Practical Guidance
- Coordinate the SHA and articles of association to avoid conflicts and gaps.
- Tailor reserved matters to actual decision-making needs, not maximum protection.
- Test exit mechanisms against realistic scenarios before finalising.
- Create valuation mechanisms that can practically operate when needed.
- Build in amendment procedures for evolving circumstances.
- Address succession and estate planning issues for individual shareholders.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Practice Areas
Need Assistance with SHA?
Our team brings deep expertise in financial & investment matters.